What do you recomend

anyone?

http://ipodlounge.com/forums/showthr...threadid=64891

Well one is plastic and the other is silicone so they are two different things...

Depends on the type of protection you want.

Plastic will provide a bit more protection from bumps and drops, but silicone is not as thick, and will protect against minor bumps and scratches.

Quote: Originally posted by Ghost311
but silicone is not as thick

Actually, that's not true. The Agent 18 case is thinner than the iSkin. I used to own an iSkin, and just bought my brother-in-law the Agent 18 case for Christmas. I've seen both, and the Agent 18 case is thinner than the iSkin.

And . . . to answer your question, I'd go with the Agent 18. Personally, after ditching my iSkin I went with the iSee case because of the dock protection. However, the Agent 18 was a close second. I ended up getting that one for my brother-in-law (see above) just because the iSee was out of stock everywhere. It's a great case.

Reason for ditching your iSkin?

Quote: Originally posted by signumnx
Reason for ditching your iSkin?

Two reasons:

(1) I decided I wanted a clear plastic case so that I could actually see the iPod. I like the white and silver body of the iPod, and didn't want it completely covered in a blue skin.

(2) The silicone skins tend to attact lint pretty easily. I found myself constantly reaching for some scotch tape so that I could remove the lint from the iSkin.

The iSkins will protect your iPod well and the screen protection works great, it just wasn't the case for me.

Well I was thinking about getting the iSkin over the Agent18 myself because of the grip. I don't know how slick the Agent18 is but I don't want to drop it.

And if and when I drop it in the Agent18, wouldn't the plastic damage the iPod in itself?

ok thanks alot guys that really helped i ended up getting the agent18 jut got it a while ago (30 min) it fits perfect and i love the protection and the way the show it off